| Platinum | Bravery Brewing |
| Gold | Scramblez Grill & Bar |
| Silver | Karen's Kitchen On Ave L |
| Bronze | Vince's Pasta & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Crazy Otto's Diner |
| Top Pick | Doublz |
| Top Pick | Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen |
| Top Pick | The Third Place Barroom and Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Tom's |
| Top Pick | York Shore House |
| Lemon Leaf Cafe |