| Platinum | Don Gus Mexican & Seafood |
| Gold | Pueblo Viejo Restaurant |
| Silver | Ranchritas Mexican Grill |
| Bronze | FatBoys Taco |
| Top Pick | Hacienda Don Cuco |
| Top Pick | Medrano's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mi Ranchito Mexican Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | Rubio's |
| Top Pick | Taqueria Pepe El Toro |
| Top Pick | Tortilla Grill |